The July meeting of the group discussed One Day by David Nicholls.
What they say
“It’s rare to find a novel which ranges over the recent past with such authority, and even rarer to find one in which the two leading characters are drawn with such solidity, such painful fidelity, to real life that you really do put the book down with the hallucinatory feeling that they’ve become as well known to you as your closest friends. Hard to imagine anyone encountering characters as well drawn as this and not recognizing the extraordinary talent of the writer who has created them.” – Jonathan Coe, Guardian ‘Books of the Year’.
“I finished it last night and I’m still quite wobbly and affected by it. It was BRILLIANT. . . the jealously nearly made me puke. I wish I’d written this book” – Marian Keyes.
What we say
One Day chronicles the lives of two university friends from 1988 to the present day. It is however a somewhat broken narrative in that the tale develops every 15th July until it reaches it’s end (or until it finally hits the wall as one member suggested).
The book comes with rave review and endorsement and is indeed very well written. It plots its way inoffensively through the ’90s, pulling in popular references along the way until it drops a bombshell towards the end – you wont want to be sitting on the bus home when this happens!
The group enjoyed the read but felt that ultimately it was not a book that as likely to stay in the mind for long. One mild criticism was that the relationship that was the focus of the story was an unlikely one. Another group member pointed out that it was a modern fairy tale and should be considered on this basis.
It might be a more interesting read for people in their 40s who will recall the fashions and music references alluded to. The Smiths et al provide the soundtrack.
August’s chosen book is Room by Emma Donohue.
Thursday 25 August 2011, 2-3pm
Manor House Library
Read one of our bloggers’ thoughts on One Day.
Have you read this book: Let us know your thoughts.
Filed under: Book review, Culture, Manor House reading group, Music, Politics, Romance, Women | Tagged: David Nicholls | Leave a comment »